Old Spice Aftershave Lotion That’s Best For Your Facial Skin

norelco 3100 old spice aftershave

Have you seen all of the hilarious Old Spice commercials and ads? Have you ever wondered if their products really work? Well, you are not alone; we too have questioned if the Old Spice aftershave is all the muscular man in the towel claims it to be.

Below we have put together a comprehensive review of the Old Spice aftershave product. We have also compared it to three of the most popular aftershaves on the market. Keep reading below to learn if there’s more to Old Spice than the funny name and witty marketing.

What Is Old Spice Aftershave?

different options to choose from Old Spice Aftershave

Old Spice aftershave is a lotion that is meant to be applied to the face after shaving. Aftershave is most commonly a liquid that contains a form of antiseptic to sterilize the skin. Most aftershaves contain additional ingredients that are used to soothe the skin and even heal any cuts that may come as a result of shaving.

Many people find that aftershave is a necessary part of their grooming routine. Aftershave not only cleans the skin, but it also helps to prevent any infections from forming. It is important to note that not all aftershaves are the same and many contain varying active ingredients and features. Additionally, although Old Spice aftershave is advertised for the male gender, women can also use aftershave products to further, cleanse, moisturize, and heal the skin.

Old Spice Aftershave Specs

Old Spice aftershave contains a small ingredient list which includes alcohol denat, water, propylene glycol, benzyl alcohol, and of course, fragrance. It is recommended that you use this product after shaving both the face and the neck. Old Spice aftershave is meant to give you a cool and refreshing feel after each use.


Old Spice is a renowned brand, and as such, can be found in many online and physical retail locations. If you are looking to purchase aftershave, you can find it in many online and physical retail outlets. The list of products includes links to Amazon.com, which is a great online merchandiser that has a wide range of products at various prices. Do not be afraid to do your research before purchasing. Many products feature customer reviews for the most unbiased feedback possible. If you are looking for additional locations to purchase aftershave, we recommend the following:

  • Sephora
  • Ulta Beauty
  • Target
  • Walmart
  • Amazon.com
  • CVS
  • Walgreens

How It Compares

We picked a few similar products available on the market to see how they compare.

Old Spice Aftershave

Old Spice Old Spice After Shave Lotion Classic 4.25 oz - 3 Pack
  • The unmistakably masculine scent of Old Spice.
  • Cool, crisp, and clean.


Old Spice is renowned for what they deem to be overtly masculine scents. The Old Spice aftershave is no different, featuring the fragrance “classic.” Unfortunately, the lack of description and scent options.


Old Spice aftershave, as we learned above, contains a very simple list of ingredients. Many other aftershaves feature active ingredients to heal skin, prevent acne, stop ingrown hairs, and more. The ingredient list for the Old Spice aftershave only promises to leave your skin feeling cool and refreshed.


Old Spice has been around for years, and that’s because they make great quality, reliable, products. The Old Spice aftershave is just reliable; however, the aftershave pales in comparison to some of its competitors on the market. Lack of additional features this aftershave offers.


  • More affordable than most aftershaves
  • Masculine and clean scent
  • Leaves you feeling cool and refreshed


  • Strong alcohol smell
  • Only one scent option
  • Meant for face and neck only

Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian for Men Aftershave

Ps By Paul Sebastian For Men. Aftershave 4.0 Oz.
  • All our fragrances are 100% originals by their original designers.
  • This item is by designer Paul Sebastian.
  • Due to manufacturer packaging changes, product packaging may vary from image shown.

Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian for Men is available in three different forms. Choose from a lotion, a splash, a deodorant, or blam. We love Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian for Men for its rich and authentic scent. If you are looking for a reliable aftershave that won’t break the bank, this is the one for you.


The fragrance of Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian for Men is a rich and musky scent which is perfect for day and nighttime use. The fragrance notes in this aftershave are as follows: amber, lavender, musk, jasmine, oakmoss, sage, ylang-ylang, and rose. If you like a darker scent, this aftershave will be perfect for you.


The ingredient list for this product is rather short. It is listed that the product contains aromatic spices, hints of florals, citrus, softwoods, and musk. Fact that we do not get an inside look into the product’s exact ingredients.


Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian for Men is an ideal aftershave if you are merely looking for an alternative to cologne. Paul Sebastian by Paul Sebastian For Men is best used as a splash or fragrance-based lotion.


  • Rich and beautiful scent
  • Strong but not overpowering scent
  • Scent lasts all day long


  • More expensive than most aftershaves
  • No additional features
  • Easy to apply too much product

Clubman After Shave Lotion

Clubman after shave lotion 6 fl oz
  • Cools, exhilerates
  • Soothers tender skin
  • Helps heal razor nicks
  • Suave, masculine fragrance

The Clubman After Shave Lotion is a cooling and exhilarating aftershave that helps heal minor cuts and nicks from your razor. The Clubman After Shave Lotion boasts a suave and masculine scent. It will also help keep your skin smooth and soothed all day long.


The Clubman After Shave Lotion is advertised to have a suave and masculine scent. The lack of fragrance list is problematic for those with allergies.


The Clubman After Shave Lotion has a very long list of ingredients. The major components of this product is the alcohol, water, and fragrance. This product also contains various tree mosses for a natural, and healing, effect.


What gives this product such a high rating is the great ingredient list. This product also has many different ingredients to help soothe, moisturize, and heal.


  • Cools and exhilarates
  • Soothes tender skin
  • Deep, masculine, fragrance


  • Not ideal for those with sensitive skin
  • Can sting after application
  • Easy to apply too much product

Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X

Proraso After Shave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning, 3.4 Fl Oz
  • Anti-irritation, for sensitive skin
  • Menthol refreshes and revitalizes
  • No parabens; No silicons; No mineral oils; No artificial colors

Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is a refreshing aftershave that contains soothing and toning properties. Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is one of the more expensive items on our list but it is also the most feature rich. If you are looking for an aftershave lotion that does it all, the Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is the product for you.

The Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is one of the more expensive aftershave lotions on the market. The reason the Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is so expensive is due to the great ingredient list. However, it is important to note that just because an aftershave is more expensive does not mean it is most effective.


The fragrance of the Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X is dominated by eucalyptus oil and menthol. If you are looking for a cool and refreshing scent, this product is perfect for you. One Amazon reviewer said “The scent doesn’t linger forever after you finish shaving, and what little bit of scent is left is not overpowering at all. It’s just enough.”


What makes the Proraso Aftershave Lotion SV-17X so great is the premium ingredients. This product contains no parabens, silicones, minter oil, artificial colors, or animal products. The ingredients are 95% natural and made in Italy.


 What makes this product so high-end is the selection of fresh and natural ingredients. This aftershave does more than just provide a pleasant scent after shaving.


  • Over 95% natural ingredients
  • Barber’s choice since 1948
  • Tones and refreshes skin


  • More expensive than more aftershaves
  • Not ideal for those with sensitive skin
  • Scent can be very strong


quality Old Spice Aftershave lotion

Looking at the list above, and the plethora of aftershave products littering the market, it can be hard to know which aftershave is right for you. First and foremost, we always recommend considering your skin type. If you have sensitive skin or acne prone skin, in particular, you will want to heavily scrutinize ingredient lists and customer reviews. For example, if you have dry skin, you should note that many aftershave lotions and splashes contain alcohol which is extremely drying to skin and can easily irritate sensitive skin.

Choosing a lotion for your skin type is key. If you are someone who likes to keep their morning routine as short as possible, opt for an aftershave that moisturizes, cleanses, soothes, and tones. If you already use a moisturizer, a cleanser, and a toner, opt for the more fragrance focused products. Lastly, make sure the product fits your budget! After all, you don’t want to splurge on one bottle, love it, and not be able to consistently afford it.

Old Spice

classic scent of Old Spice aftershave lotion

After comparing Old Spice’s aftershave to three of its fiercest competitors. Believe it or not, this product recently underwent a change in manufacturers. With the new switch, many consumers are upset with the overall quality and effectiveness of the product. One reviewer said “the scent is weak and doesn’t refresh and pleasantly linger. In fact, it smells of alcohol.”

However, that being said, Old Spice’s aftershave is still a great and affordable product. Old Spice is such a renowned brand that you can find it almost anywhere. We have even seen the Old Spice aftershave in the cosmetics aisle of the grocery store. If you have not liked the overpowering scent of Old Spice’s formulas in the past, they may just be perfect for you now! If you are looking for something that won’t leave the first impression, this is the ideal aftershave.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here